In Matthew 27:26, Mark 15:15 and John 19:1, the scourging of Jesus is narrated with striking brevity. Painters had to decide what the reader should see: a crowded public event, a confined encounter, or a solitary figure offered for contemplation. This selection follows those choices through ten historical works.
How to read a Flagellation painting
Start with the column. It may mark an architectural division, as it does in Piero’s painting, or stand close enough to make the scene feel enclosed, as in paintings of Christ at the Column. Then look at the light: does it make the whole event readable, or direct attention to a face, a shoulder or a gesture? Finally, take note of the distance between the viewer and Christ. These three decisions help explain how paintings of the same passage can feel so different.
1. The Flagellation of Christ

Three men stand in the foreground while the biblical event takes place deep in the architecture to the left. The paving and ceiling establish a remarkably legible perspective. The identities of the three men remain debated, which makes the distance between the two groups worth lingering over.
2. The Flagellation of Christ

The rising column and the illuminated figure of Christ organize a monumental vertical canvas. Bent figures cross that axis at different heights. Originally made for a church in Naples, the work makes sense at altarpiece scale, where the contrasts of light and posture carry across the room.
3. Christ at the Column

Caravaggio moves the viewer much closer in the Rouen canvas. Light falling from above picks out the figures in a shallow space against darkness. Compare the compressed grouping here with the tall, more distant arrangement of the Naples picture.
4. Christ Tied to the Column

The figure nearly fills the panel. Look to the landscape seen through the opening beside him and compare that distant view with the nearness of the body. The contrast gives a small panel both physical presence and a surprising sense of depth.
5. Christ at the Column

The close crop makes the face the center of this small devotional panel. Fine details around the eyes and mouth reward a near view. Set it beside Bramante’s version to see how differently two Renaissance painters handle the intimacy of the same subject.
6. The Flagellation of Christ

The figures share a tightly built architectural space. With its compact narrative and clearly articulated gestures, the panel shows how an Alpine painter brought spatial construction into a late Gothic Passion scene.
7. The Flagellation of Christ

This late Gothic panel rewards a look at the separate roles of the figures around the column. The centrally placed subject helps the viewer follow the episode even through the overlaps of limbs, clothes and architectural details.
8. Christ at the Column

Morales belongs to a Spanish tradition of close devotional images. The restrained grouping allows the head and the lowered posture to carry much of the expression. Small features become significant when the broader narrative recedes.
9. Christ at the Column

Fontana brings a painter’s attention to the rendering of the figure and surrounding space. Her inclusion also broadens the view of late sixteenth-century devotional painting beyond the workshops and careers usually foregrounded in surveys of the Passion.
10. The Flagellation

The eighteenth-century treatment provides a point of comparison with Caravaggio. Look at the placement of the main figure in relation to the surrounding action: after three centuries, painters were still finding new ways to give this brief Gospel episode a readable scale and rhythm.
Is Christ at the Column the same subject?
The titles refer to the same episode. A museum may use “Christ at the Column” for a close devotional image or for a scene that includes other figures, while “Flagellation” may point to the action itself. Artist, collection and composition are the most reliable way to identify a particular painting.