Gethsemane is a moment of prayer between the Last Supper and the arrest of Jesus. In historical paintings, it can unfold as a sequence of events across a landscape or become an intimate study of a single figure. These ten works make it possible to compare both traditions, from Mantegna and Bellini to Hofmann and Gauguin.
As you read each painting, locate Christ, the sleeping disciples and any figures approaching in the background. The order in which you notice them tells you what the artist made most important.
How to recognize the Agony in the Garden
Matthew 26:36–46 places the prayer at Gethsemane and describes the disciples falling asleep. Luke 22:39–46 places the episode on the Mount of Olives and, in the familiar version of the passage, includes an angel who strengthens Jesus. The cup can appear as a painted object. It gives visible form to the language Jesus uses about what lies ahead. Painters sometimes include Judas and his company as a second episode at the edge of the same picture.
Explore the ten works
- The Agony in the Garden – Andrea Mantegna
- The Agony in the Garden – Giovanni Bellini
- The Agony in the Garden – Pietro Perugino
- The Agony in the Garden – Raphael
- The Agony in the Garden – Correggio
- The Agony in the Garden – El Greco
- Christ in the Garden of Olives – Bartolomé Esteban Murillo
- Christ in the Garden of Olives – Eugène Delacroix
- Christ in Gethsemane – Heinrich Hofmann
- Christ in the Garden of Olives – Paul Gauguin
1. The Agony in the Garden – Andrea Mantegna

Mantegna makes the rock ledge an architectural support for the kneeling Christ. Cherubs show the instruments of the Passion, the disciples lie below, and the group approaching from the distance introduces what will happen next. Look at all three areas to read the sequence.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →2. The Agony in the Garden – Giovanni Bellini

Bellini knew Mantegna’s treatment of the subject. The rocky setting and sleeping disciples invite a direct comparison, while the passage of light across the landscape gives Bellini’s painting a softer rhythm. Ask where you first see the approaching group in each version.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →3. The Agony in the Garden – Pietro Perugino

Perugino gives the groups enough space to be read in sequence. Begin with the sleeping disciples below, then look to Christ above them and to the landscape beyond. The clear intervals between the figures make a crowded narrative easy to follow.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →4. The Agony in the Garden – Raphael

The predella format makes the panel wider than a single devotional portrait. Let the eye travel sideways through the garden as well as upward from the disciples to Christ. The scale of the original panel makes the clarity of the groups especially important.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →5. The Agony in the Garden – Correggio

Look for the nearest patch of light and then notice how restrained the rest of the garden is. The concentrated illumination puts the exchange around Christ at the center of the viewer’s attention.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →6. The Agony in the Garden – El Greco

El Greco’s elongated forms and abrupt shifts of scale make it difficult to measure the garden as ordinary space. Compare the angel and Christ with the cluster of sleeping disciples. The change in scale separates spiritual encounter from human sleep.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →7. Christ in the Garden of Olives – Bartolomé Esteban Murillo

Follow the lit figures before looking into the surrounding darkness. In Murillo’s treatment the scene of prayer remains legible at the center, while the subdued edges leave room for the sense of isolation.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →8. Christ in the Garden of Olives – Eugène Delacroix

Delacroix gives the encounter more weight through the contrast between the illuminated group and the shadows around it. Look at where the brightest passage falls and how the figure of Christ is supported within the arrangement.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →9. Christ in Gethsemane – Heinrich Hofmann

Hofmann isolates the kneeling Christ in a rocky setting. His face and hands make the prayer readable even at a small size. Compare this focus on a single figure with the multi-episode narrative of Mantegna.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →10. Christ in the Garden of Olives – Paul Gauguin

Gauguin gave Christ his own features. The angular shapes and closely framed head put isolation at the center of the painting. The result is a personal reading of Gethsemane and a striking change from the narrative distance of the Renaissance panels.
View this Alpha Reproduction edition →How to compare and display the paintings
For a side-by-side study, start with the Mantegna and Bellini at the National Gallery. Compare the edge of the rock, the positions of the disciples and the time of day suggested by the sky. An uncropped reproduction keeps the smaller figures in view. Hofmann or Gauguin is easier to read at a smaller scale because the center of attention is more compact.